Authentic Value

From What Money Can’t Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets by philosopher Michael J. Sandel, published in 2012:

Suppose, on your wedding day, your best man delivers a heartwarming toast, a speech so moving it brings tears to your eyes. You later learn that he didn’t write it himself but bought it online. Would you care? Would the toast mean less than it did at first, before you knew it was written by a paid professional? Most of us would probably say yes, the bought wedding toast has less value than an authentic one.

It might be argued that presidents and prime ministers routinely employ speechwriters, and no one faults them for it. But a wedding toast is not a State of the Union address. It is an expression of friendship. Although a bought toast might “work” in the sense of achieving its desired effect, that effect might depend on an element of deception. Here’s a test: If, seized with anxiety at the prospect of giving a speech at your best friend’s wedding, you purchased a moving, sentimental masterpiece online, would you reveal this fact, or try to cover it up? If a bought toast depends for its effect on concealing its provenance, that’s a reason to suspect it’s a corrupt version of the real thing. Apologies and wedding toasts are goods that can, in a sense, be bought. But buying and selling them changes their character and diminishes their value.

Somehow both timely/timeless. In the book, Sandel argues more broadly about the limits of markets and, he argues, the denigrating, morally corrupting force of putting a price on everything, especially those things that perhaps should not be bought and sold.

He actually wasn’t writing or thinking about AI, and yet, regardless of the market forces at play, I think the broader point about authenticity stands. When we are confronted by—not just slop—but even high-quality AI output, we are still disappointed that it’s not a real person, spending their real energy, giving the gift of their limited attention.

Leave a Reply